The Pharma Career Ladder · The first-line manager · Step 4: Coaching · Lesson 2

Ask before you tell

Why the rep who finds the answer keeps it

By Ahmed El Menshawy · 20 years in pharma, from medical rep to country manager in the UAE. Founder of RepPharma. LinkedIn
Published

The fastest way to coach a rep is also the least useful one.

You watch the call. You see the problem in the first minute. So in the debrief you say it: "Next time, open with the patient type."

The rep nods. The next call improves a little. And the month after, the same rep is waiting for you to fix the next call.

Most of us learned to debrief this way. It feels efficient.

What changed my debriefs was one habit: ask before you tell.

"How do you think the opening landed with her?"

Then stay quiet.

  • When I tell, I do the thinking and the rep takes away my answer for one doctor on one day.
  • When I ask, the rep does the thinking and takes away a way of looking at any call.

Whitmore built GROW on this idea. Michael Bungay Stanier puts it simply in The Coaching Habit: stay curious a little longer, and give advice a little more slowly.

Two warnings from my own practice.

A leading question is still telling. "Don't you think you should have..." fools nobody.

And asking does not mean never telling. If the rep could not see it, say it. Just ask first.

“Tell, and the rep learns your answer. Ask, and the rep learns to find one.”
Ask before you tell: Why the rep who finds the answer keeps it

Lesson 2 of 23 in Step 4: Coaching, with the full guide and a checklist for this week.

More lessons in step 4: Coaching

Lesson 1The 10-minute debriefUsing the GROW model in the car after a doctor callLesson 3One skill at a timeWhy a double visit needs a single focusLesson 4Feedback that changes behaviourSituation, behaviour, impact after a double visitLesson 5Praise that means somethingSpecific, timely and namedLesson 6The coaching logOne line per call, patterns over a monthLesson 7Coaching a strong repStretch, not correctionLesson 8Coaching a struggling repDiagnose skill or will before you actLesson 9When the rep does not want coachingResistance is informationLesson 10Coaching by phoneWhen you cannot be in the field togetherLesson 11Modelling the call yourselfWhen to show it and when to stay quietLesson 12The development plan that is usedOne page, one skill, one dateLesson 13Coaching the openingThe thirty seconds most worth fixingLesson 14Coaching questioningTeaching a rep to stop pitchingLesson 15Coaching objection handlingRehearsal beats adviceLesson 16Role play without humiliationMaking practice safe and usefulLesson 17The seven-day follow-upCoaching without follow-up is only a conversationLesson 18Coaching across a cycleWhat to work on in month one, two and threeLesson 19Group coaching in a cycle meetingTeaching twelve reps without boring tenLesson 20Measuring whether coaching workedBehaviour seen on calls, not sessions heldLesson 21Coaching yourselfReviewing your own day as honestly as a rep's callLesson 22The coaching conversation nobody wantsWhen the issue is attitude, not abilityLesson 23Building a coaching habitSame day, same rhythm, every cycle

Coaching, in RepPharma

Plans approved in one click

Each rep’s monthly plan is drafted from doctor priority and visit frequency; you review and approve it in one click.

Team reviews that assemble themselves

Monthly team reviews are built from field data, and a month-end checklist shows which reps have next month’s plan, forecast and expenses in.

Forecasts graded against real sales

Bottom-up forecasts per account and product are graded against real sales every month.

A new step every week in the Pharma Career Ladder newsletter on LinkedIn.